In 2021, a team of researchers from Carnegie Melon University (CMU) dove deep into the role that browser tabs play in our day-to-day work. Their research was significant in that it identified a root cause of one of today’s most burning problems at the desktop, in tab hoarding. They called the phenomenon the ‘black hole effect’, likening it to a vast digital universe where every open browser tab is a tiny star, each representing a piece of information, a task to complete, or a reminder of things to come. As users navigate this universe, they find themselves surrounded by an ever-increasing number of these stars, reluctant to let any of them fade away.
The CMU team’s research uncovered competing pressures in tab management: the fear of losing information versus the need to declutter. While closing tabs frees up space, it risks plunging valuable insights into a digital black hole, making them difficult to retrieve. Even bookmarks and archived tabs often become forgotten constellations—out of sight, out of mind.
But tab hoarding wasn’t just about keeping information accessible—it was about preserving progress and avoiding the mental burden of retracing steps. Each open tab represented unfinished business, a task in limbo, or a potential missed opportunity.
To address this, the CMU team proposed intelligent archiving, activity-based tab grouping, and even futuristic tech that could automatically resurface relevant tabs. Yet, such automation remained beyond today’s desktop capabilities.
The ‘black hole effect’ highlights how web browsing has outpaced the tools used to manage it, turning the once-simple browser into a cognitive and productivity burden—popularly known as tab overload.
While CMU’s research shed light on the psychology behind tab hoarding, it left a crucial question unanswered:
What role does technology play in the tab hoarding problem?